FS19 engine sound ...

[W1der]

So, I have been looking at some FS19 clips ...

I remember from first impressions of FS17 that the engine sound was a huge improvement over FS15.
Not sure what to think about the sound in FS19.

What do you guys think?

[Gimli54]

I’ve always thought it was good especially considering they go and get it from the actual tractors themselves so I’ve never had a problem with them

[redglasses]

meh they haven't really been the best, is it just me or do they seem computerized in fs17. Also a bit copy and paste, I wish you could hear them from further. Anyone who has been any where close to a combine knows you can hear that humming from half way across the field.

[Gimli54]

Or an air drill, those things are like a screaming banshee hit between the legs

[Guil]

Believe me the sounds are amazing. On a hill top you can hear the wind howling. It's quiet beautiful actually.

[Vanilleeis]

As long as they dont deliver gearbox and switch sounds, the tractors will always sound way too linear. Squeaking and all those little immersive sounds are missing too. I started Fs19 and wanted to hear the sounds of the John Deere tractors and they are among the worst. Huge disappointment imo.

[redglasses]

Believe me the sounds are amazing. On a hill top you can hear the wind howling. It's quiet beautiful actually.

We're talking about engine sounds though

[Guil]

So was I, all sounds though.

[ClassicTractors]

I think the sounds in FS19 are a big improvement from FS17.

[W1der]

Seriously?

Must be something wrong with my sound ... all I am hearing is "sowing machines" when I press the gas pedal!
...

In cabin I need to crank the volume up to be able to hear if I have my indicators turned on ... and outside I need to get really close (zoom out and it goes dead silent).

This big contrast in the engine sound volume is driving me nuts!

[tom5051]

The vehicles do not sound as good as FS17. The music *censored* too but hey, I'll just use my own.

[jackwi]

The engine sound is terrible and the horn well its more then terrible

[RODHA]

In cabin I need to crank the volume up to be able to hear if I have my indicators turned on ... and outside I need to get really close (zoom out and it goes dead silent).

There is a ridiculous amount of sound deadening in the cab. Really getting into my nerves.
On the other hand engine sounds are almost identical to real life counter parts.
I have been watching real life farming videos for a long time and almost no tractor sounds even close to what they sounded in FS17.
FS17 sounds are cool and lovely. But not real.
Which one I like more? Well, without a doubt FS17. Cause every tractor had a character with those fine tuned sounds.
May be some overdozing on the reality part here.

[fenixguy]

I like realistic sounds. Most of the tractors in 17 sounded like an air compressor running all of the time.

[cr41g_1965]

Mudrunner has great sounds... those dirty Russian trucks, especially the B-131 starting up can melt your heart